Misplaced Pages

Revision as of 16:57, 29 June 2010

The neutrality of this article is disputed. Relevant discussion may be found on the talk page. Please do not remove this message until conditions to do so are met. (May 2010) (Learn how and when to remove this message)

This article may require cleanup to meet Misplaced Pages's quality standards. No cleanup reason has been specified. Please help improve this article if you can. (May 2010) (Learn how and when to remove this message)

Part of a series on
Judaism
Movements Conservative Conservadox Humanistic Karaite Orthodox Haredi Hasidic Modern Reform Reconstructionist Renewal
Philosophy Principles of faith Kabbalah Messiah Ethics Chosenness God Names Musar movement
Texts Tanakh Torah Nevi'im Ketuvim Ḥumash Siddur Piyutim Zohar Rabbinic Mishnah Talmud Midrash Tosefta
Law Mishneh Torah Tur Shulchan Aruch Mishnah Berurah Aruch HaShulchan Kashrut Tzniut Tzedakah Niddah Noahide laws
Holy cities/places Jerusalem Safed Hebron Tiberias Synagogue Beth midrash Mikveh Sukkah Chevra kadisha Holy Temple Tabernacle
Important figures Abraham Isaac Jacob Moses Aaron David Solomon Sarah Rebecca Rachel Leah Rabbinic sages Chazal Tannaim Amoraim Savoraim Geonim Rishonim Acharonim
Religious roles Rabbi Rebbe Posek Hazzan Dayan Rosh yeshiva Mohel Kohen
Culture and education Brit Zeved habat Pidyon haben Bar and bat mitzvah Marriage Bereavement Yeshiva Kollel Cheder
Ritual objects Sefer Torah Tallit Tefillin Tzitzit Kippah Mezuzah Menorah Shofar Four species Etrog Lulav Hadass Arava Kittel Gartel
Prayers Shema Amidah Aleinu Kaddish Minyan Birkat Hamazon Shehecheyanu Hallel Havdalah Tachanun Kol Nidre Selichot (S'lichot)
Major holidays Rosh Hashanah Yom Kippur Sukkot Pesach Shavuot Purim Hanukkah
Other religions Christianity Hinduism Islam Mormonism Samaritanism Abrahamic religions Judeo-Christian Pluralism
Related topics Jews Zionism Israel Pilegesh Haymanot Criticism Antisemitism Anti-Judaism Holocaust theology Music Jesus Muhammad
Judaism portal
v t e

Criticism of Judaism includes criticisms that address Judaism's religious doctrines, religious texts, religious laws, religious practices, and the consequences of those laws and practices. Some early criticism originated in inter-faith polemics between Christianity and Judaism. Several important disputations in the Middle Ages gave rise to widely publicized criticisms, as well as some antisemitic canards. Some modern criticisms reflect the inter-branch schisms that distinguish the various modern formulations of Judaism, such as Orthodox Judaism, Conservative Judaism, and Reform Judaism. Some criticisms—such as criticisms of policies that discriminate against women—are aimed primarily at the more traditional branches of Judaism.

Doctrines and precepts

Personal God

Baruch Spinoza, Mordecai Kaplan, and prominent atheists criticize Judaism because its theology and religious texts describe a personal God which has conversations with important figures from ancient Judaism (Moses, Abraham, etc.) and forms relationships and covenants with the Jewish people. Spinoza and Kaplan instead believed God is abstract, impersonal, or a force of nature. Theologian and philosopher Franz Rosenzweig suggested that the two viewpoints are both valid and are complementary within Judaism.

Chosen people

Most branches of Judaism consider Jews to be the "chosen people", in the sense that they have special role to "preserve God's revelations" or to "affirm our common humanity". This attitude is reflected, for example, in the policy statement of Reform Judaism which holds that Jews have a responsibility to "cooperate with all men in the establishment of the kingdom of God, of universal brotherhood, Justice, truth and peace on earth." Some secular and critics affiliated with other religions claim the concept implies favoritism or superiority, as have some Jewish critics, such as Baruch Spinoza. Antisemitic individuals and groups often cite the concept of chosenness in their criticisms of Judaism. Many Jews find the concept of chosenness problematic or an anachronism, and such concerns led to the formation of Reconstructionist Judaism, whose founder, Mordecai Kaplan, rejected the concept of the Jews as the chosen people and argued that the view of the Jews as the chosen people was ethnocentric.

Land ownership conflicts in Middle East

Critics claim that religious Zionism's precepts have led to land ownership conflicts and expulsion of peoples in the Middle East. Specifically, some critics cite the Tanakh's (Jewish Bible's) notion of a "Promised Land" (ha-Aretz ha-Muvtachat) - which promises to the Jews the "Land of Israel" (Eretz Israel) - as a factor in the settlement of the Middle East, as described by one analyst: "Zionism aspires to restore the Biblical promised boundaries. It is a new manifestation of the ancient aspiration for the Land of Israel promised in the Bible." Critics also claim that verses from the Tanakh (Jewish Bible) are used to provide religious justifcation and motivation for confiscation and expulsion, citing specificially Numbers 33:50–55: However, many religious leaders consider Zionism to be political, not religious concept; and some believe that returning to the promised land in moderns times should be discouraged.

Historical accuracy of origins and foundations

See also Historicity of Hebrew bible, Documentary Hypothesis

Some critics claim that many events and figures that are central to the formation of Judaism and its laws are historically implausible, including the events surrounding the Exodus, the tradition that the Torah was written by Moses, and the events surrounding the battle of Jericho. Some scholars, however, reject the notion that the Tanakh should be considered an historical work, emphasizing the role of myth, legend, and folk motifs played in its origin, or note the modern conception of history is much different than the views held in the past. Also, some branches of Judaism do not interpret these narratives literally, and many Jews consider those narratives to be metaphorical or allegorical.

Inter-branch criticisms

Criticism of Conservative Judaism from other branches

Conservative Judaism is criticized by some leaders of Orthodox Judaism for not properly following Halakha (Jewish religious law). It is also criticized by some leaders of Reform Judaism for being at odds with the principles of its young adult members on issues such as intermarriage, patrilineal descent, and the ordination of lesbians and gay men—all issues that Conservative Judaism opposes and Reform Judaism supports. (The Conservative movement has since moved in the direction of allowing for gay rabbis and the "celebration of same-sex commitment ceremonies.")

Criticism of traditional Judaism by reform movement

The reform movement grew out of dissatisfaction with several aspects of traditional Judaism or Rabbinic Judaism, and these dissatisfactions were documented in polemics and other writings during the 19th and early 20th century. Louis Jacobs, A prominent Masorti Rabbi, described the polemics beween the Orthodox and the Reform movements as follows:

"The polemics between Orthodox, as the traditionalists came to be called, and the Reformers were fierce. The Orthodox treated Reform as rank heresy, as no more than a religion of convenience which, if followed, would lead Jews altogether out of Judaism. The Reformers retorted that, on the contrary, the danger to Jewish survivial was occasioned by the Orthodox who, through their obscurantism, failed to see that the new challenges facing Judaism had to be faced consciously in the present as Judaism had faced, albeit unconsciously, similar challenges in the past."

— Louis Jacobs, The Jewish religion: a companion, Oxford University Press, p. 4. (1995)

David Einhorn, an American Reform rabbi, calls Reform Judaism a "liberation" of Judaism :

"There is at present a rent in Judaism which affects its very life, and which no covering, however glittering, can repair. The evil which threatens to corrode gradually all the healthy bone and marrow must be completely eradicated, and this can be done only if, in the name and in the interest of the religion, we remove from the sphere of our religious life all that is corrupt and untenable, and solemnly absolve ourselves from all obligations toward it in the future; thus we may achieve the liberation of Judaism for ourselves and for our children, so as to prevent the estrangement from Judaism."

— David Einhorn, Philipson, David (1907) The Reform Movement in Judaism, Macmillian.

The criticisms of traditional Judaism included criticisms asserting that the Torah's laws are not strictly binding; criticisms asserting that many ceremonies and rituals are not necessary; criticisms asserting that Rabbincal leadership is too authoritarian; criticisms asserting that there was too much superstition; criticisms asserting that traditional Judaism leads to isolation from other communities; and criticisms asserting that traditional Judaism over-emphasized the exile.

Some of these criticisms were anticipated in a much earlier time, by philosopher Uriel da Costa (1585–1640) who criticized the Rabbinic authorities and the Talmud for lack of authenticity and spirituality.

Violence

Ancient

Judaism has been criticized because its religious texts allegedly endorse or glorify violence, including violence against innocent peoples. The battle of Jericho (Joshua 6:1–27), the story of Amalekites (1 Sam 15:1–6), the story of the Midianites (Numbers 31:1–18), and the Purim festival are cited as sources of violent attitudes that are allegedly endorsed by Judaism and its religious texts. However, modern religious authorities repudiate the sort of warfare described in the Torah, or claim that the events were exaggerated or metaphorical. Others point out that while religious texts have been used to justify violence, Jewish traditions mitigate calls to violent actions, Jewish law holds that the calls to violence these texts provide no longer apply, or that Jewish theology instructs Jews to leave vengeance to God.

Modern

Judaism has been associated with violent and terrorist individuals and organizations in modern times, such as Gush Emunim Underground (formed by members of Gush Emunim), Brit HaKanaim, the Jewish Defense League founded in 1969 by Rabbi Meir Kahane, Kach and Kahane Chai, Yaakov Teitel, and Baruch Goldstein, perpetrator of the Cave of the Patriarchs Massacre. However, such instances of religious violence are considered by many to be extremist aberrations, and not representative of the tenets of Judaism.

Discrimination

Laws that discriminate against non-Jews

Judaism has been criticized because its religious laws contain several provisions that discriminate against non-Jews, such as the rule that there is no need to return lost property belonging to non-Jews, and the asymmetry in compensation rules following ox-goring incidents. Some of Judaism's precepts have been criticized because they could be interpreted to mean that Jews should not violate the Sabbath in order to save non-Jews that are dying. Some critics point to the fact that the Talmud includes the maxim " are neither to be lifted out of a well nor hauled down into it." Critics also cite the writings of Maimonides (1137–1204), an important Rabbinical commentator, who wrote "as for gentiles , the basic Talmudic principle is that their lives must not be saved, although it is also forbidden to murder them outright."

However, religious authorities point out that those religious dicta must be interpreted within the context that they were created, and that non-Jews in that context were idolaters. In addition, arguments against such discrimination were posited by leading rabbis starting in the Middle Ages, and the rules are no longer enforced. All rabbinic authorities agree that the Sabbath should be violated to save any human life, including non-Jews.

Women

Divorce and agunah

Judaism, particularly the Orthodox formulation, has been criticized because its religious laws can sometimes result in women being trapped in abusive relationships, and for tolerating the status of agunah. Many criticisms focus on the fact that women may be trapped in a marriage, because divorce cannot be granted without the husband's consent, and some husbands refuse to grant the consent. However, the Reform Judaism and Conservative Judaism formulations permit women to obtain divorces without the consent of husbands.

Inequality

Judaism has been criticized because some of its religious laws and religious texts are alleged to treat women with a status inferior to men, including exclusion from some rituals and ceremonies, being rabbis or holding certain other positions of authority, which sometimes leads women to feel helpless, powerless, and like outsiders. Some critics blame Judaism and its religious texts for being the source of widespread patriarchal attitudes in the modern world. Author Naomi Gaetz addresses the fact that some feminists blame the Judaism for being the source of many sexist beliefs, and quotes Tikva Frymer-Kensky "Israel was neither the creator of patriarchy, nor the worst perpetrator in the ancient world.…Nevertheless, we make a profound statement when we acknowledge that the Bible is patriarchal. We are brought to the realization that the Bible contains a fundamental moral flaw: it does not treat all humans as equals." Reform Judaism and Conservative Judaism generally provide women with privileges comparable to men.

Niddah (menstruation laws)

Judaism has been criticized because the religious rules governing menstruation (generally known as niddah) are claimed to cause some women to view their bodies as damaged, and to cause some women to feel oppressed. Tova Hartman wrote "The rules that govern religious women's bodies are often criticized as oppressive methods of domination". However, one commentator noted that "Rabbinic commentary did not unilaterally focus on the menstruating woman as pariah. For every statement stressing defilement, danger, and impurity, exists a counter-statement emphasizing respect toward women, the holiness of sexual intimacy, and the incidental benefits of sexual regulation and restraint."

Homosexuality

Judaism has been criticized because its religious texts condemn homosexual activity, and because some branches, such as Orthodox Judaism, prohibit homosexual activity. Orthodox Judaism does not, however, exclude homosexual individuals. Although Conservative Judaism traditionally disallowed homosexuals from serving in official capacities, in 2006 the Committee on Jewish Law and Standards of the Rabbinical Assembly voted to allow homosexuals to become rabbis adopting a position similar to that held by Reform Judaism, which accepts gay and lesbian members and does not oppose homosexuals serving as rabbis or cantors.

Hostility towards other faiths

See also: Christian-Jewish disputations

Persecution of early Christians

Judaism has been criticized because it is alleged that leaders of Judaism, particularly during the first few centuries CE, persecuted Christians. In opposition to this view, many historians conclude that the Romans were responsible for the death of Jesus, and the Roman Catholic church issued a proclamation absolving modern Jews of collective guilt for the death. Some critics also include the death of Jesus as an example of persecution of early Christians, claiming that leaders of Judaism played a key role in bringing about the death of Jesus.

Insults directed at Jesus

Judaism has been criticized because the Talmud, the Tosefta, and the Toldoth Yeshu are claimed to refer to Jesus in an insulting manner, such as: stating that Jesus is condemned to hell and boiled in excrement; stating that he was executed for sorcery; stating that his mother Mary was a whore or adulterer; and identifying Jesus by the Hebrew name Yeshu which, it is alleged, is not a short form of the name Yeshua, but rather an acrostic signifying "may his name and memory be blotted out". However, many scholars of Judaism maintain that the person identified as Yeshu in the Talmud is not Jesus. In addition, the general trend in Judaism over the past two thousand years has been to treat Jesus with increasing sympathy.

Practices

Shechitah (ritual slaughter)

Judaism's practice of shechitah (ritual slaughter of animals) has been criticized by animal rights groups, such as PETA, for being cruel and inhumane. However, proponets of the practice claim that shechitah is painless because the animal quickly loses consciousness.

Brit milah (covenant of circumcision)

Judaism has been criticized for encouraging or requiring brit milah, a circumcision ritual performed on young boys, because the ritual is alleged to be painful, cruel, tantamount to genital mutilation, and without the boy's consent. An anti-brit milah movement is active in some branches of Judaism. However, many view brit milah as an important religious ritual, involving only minor pain.

See also

References

• Acosta , Uriel Examination of Pharisaic traditions, reprinted in Volume 44 of Brill's studies in intellectual history (Edited and translated by Herman Prins Salomon, I. S. D. Sassoon). BRILL, 1993 ISBN 9004099239. Online here.
• Hartman, Tova (2007). Feminism encounters traditional Judaism: resistance and accommodation. UPNE.
• Hirst, David (2003). The gun and the olive branch: the roots of violence in the Middle East By. Nation Books. ISBN 1560254831.
• Horowitz, Elliott S. (2006). Reckless rites: Purim and the legacy of Jewish violence. Princeton University Press. ISBN 0691124914.
• Kalechofsky, Roberta (1992). Judaism and animal rights: classical and contemporary responses. Micah Publications. ISBN 0916288358.
• Lustick, Ian (1988). For the land and the Lord: Jewish fundamentalism in Israel. Council on Foreign Relations. ISBN 0876090366.
• Rushkoff, Douglas (2004). Nothing Sacred: The Truth About Judaism. Three Rivers Press.
• Schwartzchild, Steven, "The Question of Jewish Ethics Today" (Dec, 24, 1976) in journal Sh'ma (vol. 7, no. 124) online here. Reprinted in The pursuit of the ideal: Jewish writings of Steven Schwarzschild, chapter 7, pp 117–136, SUNY Press, 1990 (ISBN 0791402193).
• Scult, Mel (1993). Judaism faces the twentieth century: a biography of Mordecai M. Kaplan. Wayne State University Press. ISBN 0814322808.
• Shahak, Israël (1994). Jewish history, Jewish religion: the weight of three thousand years. Pluto Press. ISBN 0745308198.
• Shmueli, Ephraim (1990). Seven Jewish cultures: a reinterpretation of Jewish history and thought. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0521373816.
• Spinoza, Baruch (1909). Short treatise on God, man, and human welfare. The Open Court Pub. Co. Online here.

Notes

1. ^ Nadler, Steven (2001). Spinoza: a life. Cambridge University Press. pp. 66–72, 135–136, 145–146, 274–281. ISBN 0521002931.
2. ^ Kertzer, Morris N. (1999) "What is a Jew?" in Introduction to Judaism: A Source Book (Stephen J. Einstein, Lydia Kukoff, Eds.), Union for Reform Judaism, 1999, p. 243
3. ^ Dawkins, Richard (2006). The God delusion. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. p. 37, 245. ISBN 0618680004.
4. Oppenheim, Michael D. (1997). Speaking/writing of God: Jewish philosophical reflections. SUNY press. p. 107.
5. Wilhoit, Francis M. (1979). The quest for equality in freedom. Transaction Publishers. p. 13. ISBN 0878552405.
6. Goodheart, Eugene (2004). Confessions of a secular Jew: a memoir. Transaction Publishers. pp. xv–xvi, 83. ISBN 0765805995.
7. "The Guiding Principles of Reform Judaism, Columbus, [[Ohio]], 1937". {{cite web}}: URL–wikilink conflict (help)
8. Wistrich, Robert S. Demonizing the other: antisemitism, racism & xenophobia. Taylor & Francis, 1999. p. 6. ISBN 9057024977.
9. • Eliezer Schwied (2007) "Does the Idea of Jewish Election Have Any Meaning after the Holocaust?". In Wrestling with God: Jewish theological responses during and after the Holocaust, Steven T. Katz, Shlomo Biderman (Eds.); Oxford University Press, p 233.
   • Gürkan, S. Leyla (2008). The Jews as a Chosen People: Tradition and Transformation. Taylor & Francis. pp. 49–55. ISBN 0415466075.
10. ^ Dennis Prager; Joseph Telushkin (2003). Why the Jews?: the reason for antisemitism. Touchstone. p. 26. ISBN 0743246209. Cite error: The named reference "WhyTheJews1" was defined multiple times with different content (see the help page).
11. • Hertzberg, Arthur (1998). Judaism. Simon and Schuster. pp. 56–57. ISBN 0684852659.
    • Pasachoff, Naomi E. (2005). A concise history of the Jewish people. Rowman & Littlefield. p. 276. ISBN 0742543668.
12. ^ Salaita, Steven George (2006). The Holy Land in transit: colonialism and the quest for Canaan. Syracuse University Press. p. 54. ISBN 081563109X.
13. • Hirst, David (2003). The gun and the olive branch: the roots of violence in the Middle East By. Nation Books. pp. 418–419. ISBN 1560254831.
    • Chomsky, Noam (1996). World orders, old and new. Columbia University Press. p. 264:. ISBN 0231101570,. {{cite book}}: Check |isbn= value: invalid character (help)CS1 maint: extra punctuation (link)
    • "FrontPage magazine interview with Christopher Hitchens". December 11, 2003.
    • Masalha, Nur (2000). Imperial Israel and the Palestinians: the politics of expansion. Pluto Press. p. 93. ISBN 0745316158.
    • "Essay by James M. Martin from "Atheist Nexus"".
    • Quigley, John B. (1990). Palestine and Israel: a challenge to justice. Duke University Press. pp. 176–177. ISBN 0822310236.
    • Chomsky, Noam (1999). Fateful triangle: the United States, Israel, and the Palestinians (2nd Ed, revised). South End Press. pp. 153–154. ISBN 0896086011.
    • Saleh Abdel Jawad (2007) "Zionist Massacres: the Creation of the Palestinian Refugee Problem in the 1948 War" in Israel and the Palestinian refugees, Eyal Benvenistî, Chaim Gans, Sari Hanafi (Eds.), Springer, p. 78.
    • Yishai, Yael (1987). Land or peace: whither Israel?. Hoover Press. pp. 112–125. ISBN 0817985212.
    • Rubenberg, Cheryl (2003). The Palestinians: in search of a just peace. Lynne Rienner Publishers. p. 162. ISBN 1588262251.
    • Geaves, Ron (2004). Islam and the West post 9/11. Ashgate Publishing, Ltd. p. 31. ISBN 0754650057.
14. Masalha, Nur (2007). The Bible and Zionism: invented traditions, archaeology and post-colonialism in Palestine-Israel. Zed Books. p. 194. ISBN 1842777610.
15. Harkabi, Yehoshafat (1974). Arab attitudes to Israel. John Wiley and Sons. p. 75. ISBN 0470352035.
16. • Kassim, Anis F. (2000). The Palestine Yearbook of International Law, 1998-1999, Volume 10. Martinus Nijhoff Publishers. p. 9. ISBN 9041113045.
    • Raphael Israeli, Palestinians Between Israel and Jordan', Prager, 1991, pages 158-159, 171, 182.
17. • Schimmel, Solomon (2008). The tenacity of unreasonable beliefs: fundamentalism and the fear of truth. Oxford University Press US. p. 39,56,61,240. ISBN 0195188268.
    • Mendes-Flohr, Paul (2009). 20th Century Jewish Religious Thought. Jewish Publication Society. p. 681. ISBN 0827608926,. {{cite book}}: Check |isbn= value: invalid character (help)CS1 maint: extra punctuation (link)
    • John Van Seters (2004) "Historicity of Moses", in The Biblical World (vol 2), John Barton (Ed.); Taylor & Francis. pp 194-207.
    • Thomas M. Bolin (2004) "Warfare and the Hebrew Bible", in The Biblical World (vol 2), John Barton (Ed.); Taylor & Francis. p. 45.
    • David Novak (1993) "The Election of Israel: Outline of a Philosphical analysis", in A People apart: chosenness and ritual in Jewish philosophical thought Daniel H. Frank (Ed.) SUNY Press, 1993; p. 22
18. Redmount, Carol A. "Bitter Lives: Israel In And Out of Egypt". The Oxford History of the Biblical World: pp.63–64. {{cite journal}}: |page= has extra text (help)
19. Coogan, Michael D. "In the Beginning: The Earliest History". The Oxford History of the Biblical World: p.22. {{cite journal}}: |page= has extra text (help)
20. Thompson, Thomas L. (November 2002). The historicity of the patriarchal narratives: the quest for the historical. Trinity Press International. p. 187. {{cite book}}: Text "isbn: 1563383896" ignored (help)
21. Adele Berlin, Marc Zvi Brettler, Michael Fishbane, Michael A. Fishbane. The Jewish study Bible. Jewish Publication Society. p. 11, 103–105, 452–454. ISBN 0195297512. {{cite book}}: Text "language: English" ignored (help); Text "publisher: Oxford University Press, USA (January 4, 2004)" ignored (help)CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
22. Avi Shafran, "The Conservative Lie", Moment, February 2001.
23. Joe Berkofsky, "Death of Conservative Judaism? Reform leader’s swipe sparks angry rebuttals", j., March 5, 2004.
24. ^ Laurie Goodstein, Conservative Jews Allow Gay Rabbis and Unions, The New York Times, 2006.
25. ^ Shmueli, Efraim (1990) Seven Jewish cultures: a reinterpretation of Jewish history and thought Cambridge University Press, p. 123, 167-168, 172-174, 177, 261.
26. • "Abraham Geiger ... stressed the belief in progress: the Bible and Talmud represent an early, primitive stage in a revelation that is still continuing. Many traditional ceremonies (such as circumcision) are distressing to modern sensibility or incompatible with modern life... Geiger become increasingly convinced of the need to 'dethrone the Talmud'... " - De Lange, Nicholas (2000),An introduction to Judaism, Cambridge University Press, p. 73
    • "According to Kaplan, the Jewish heritage, including the belief in God, must be reinterpreted so that it will be consistent with the intellectual outlook of the twentieth century. The Torah, which is Jewish civilization in practice, must be given a new functional interpretation." - Scult, Mel (1993) Judaism faces the twentieth century: a biography of Mordecai M. Kaplan, Wayne State University Press, p. 341.
    • "Israel drew within herself, shunned the world, and lived apart. In her seclusion her religion became her all. The interpretation of the Law and the constuction put upon the commandments tended toward the upholding of the letter rather than the spirit. ... Reform was born to protect the spirit of the Law, to place the spirit above the letter, to make the latter subservieint to the former.... The abolition of those forms and ceremonies that were not conducive to proper living, or that had, by reason of altered environment, become meaningless, was of the highest importance to the spiritual welfare of Israel." - Stern, Myer (1895), The rise and progress of reform Judaism: , Harvard University, p. 5.
27. • "Reform Judaism rejected the concept of Divine revelation, and ... the law is considered instructional and inspirational but not binding, ... and by eliminating many ritual practices..." - Dosick, Wayne D. (1995), Living Judaism: the complete guide to Jewish belief, tradition, and practice, HarperCollins, p. 62.
    • "Reform Judaism first took hold in Germany in the early nineteenth century. This tradition asserts that many of the ritualistic practices and dogmas of the past are outmoded..... Reform Jews assumed a prerogative to choose which Biblical laws were worthy of their allegiance and which were not.... Orthodox Jews adhere to a literal interpretation of the Hebrew Bible and continue to observe all the traditional Jewish laws... Conservative Jews ... were ... less likely than the Orthodox to accept the infallibilty of sacred texts asserting that 'the divine origin of Jewish law ... to human development and application'". - Berger, Ronald J. (2002), Fathoming the Holocaust: a social problems approach, Aldine Transaction, p. 179-180.
    • "We hold that all such Mosaic and rabbinical laws as regulate diet, priestly purity, and dress originated in ages and under the influence of ideas entirely foreign to our present mental and spiritual state. They fail to impress the modern Jew with a spirit of priestly holiness; their observance in our days is apt rather to obstruct than to further modern spiritual elevation." - Pittsburgh Platform, section 4.
    • "...in the view of rabbinical Judaism every command of the written law in the Pentateuch (Torah sh'bikthab), and of the oral law (Torah sh'b'al peh), as codified in the Shulchan Aruk, is equally binding. The ceremonial law has equal potency with the religious and moral commands. Reform Judaism, on the other hand, claims that a distinction must be made between the universal precepts of religion and morality and the enactments arising from the circumstances and conditions of special times and places. Customs and ceremonies must change with the varying needs of different generations. Successive ages have their individual requirements for the satisfaction of the religious nature. No ceremonial law can be eternally binding. " - Philipson, David (1907) The Reform Movement in Judaism, Macmillian (reprinted by University of California, 2007), p. 5-6.
28. • ".. the immense authoritarian power of the orthodox Rabbis and Hasidic Zadikkim in the traditionalist communities ... As a result, there was open conflict between the rebellious youth .. and the religious establishment.... This was the context in which a virulent 'anti-clericalism' developed among progressive Jewish intellectuals, leaving countless evidence in the shape of polemical articles, autobiographical works, and imaginative literature." - Lowy, Michael (1992), Redemption and utopia: Jewish libertarian thought in Central Europe : a study in elective affinity, Stanford University Press, p. 45.
    • " originally founded as a response by Jewish laity to the perceived authoritarian rigidity of traditional or Orthodox Judaism and its rabbis." - Palmer-Fernández, Gabriel (2004), The encyclopedia of religion and war, Routledge, p. 253.
    • "Mosaism and rabbinic Judaism were appropriate for earlier ages, argued. But the age of man's maturity called for freedom from the letter, from blind authority, 'from all restriction which curb the minds and encroach upon the hearts'. The contemporary Jew had 'outgrown the guiding strings ... of infancy'; he was ready to walk on his own. What he required was not law, but a 'living Judaism', both enlightened and pious, appealling to reason and emotion." - Meyer, Michael A. (1995) Response to modernity: a history of the Reform Movement in Judaism, Wayne State University Press, p. 267.
    • "There is a fatal split among Jews, first, because religious tenets and institutions have been kept forcibly on a level of a vanished era, and not permeated with the divine breath of refreshing life, while life itself hurried forward stormily; and secondly, because the religious leaders, lacking all knowledge of the world and of men, dreamed of other times and conditions, and held themselves aloof from the life of the new generation - hence resulted a superficial rationalism, inimical to all positive and historical faith, side by side with a rigid, unreasoning formalism". - Philipson, David (1907) The Reform Movement in Judaism, Macmillian (reprinted by University of California, 2007), (quoting Abraham Kohn, rabbi of Hohemems in Tirol); p. 93-95.
29. • "Emancipation implied the breakdown of the Jews' millennial social and cultural isolation ... It was said for the first time in European history the Jews could participate in non-Jewish culture without the stigma of apostacy". Mendes-Flohr, Paul R. (1995). The Jew in the modern world: a documentary history. Oxford University Press US,. p. 155. ISBN 019507453X,. {{cite book}}: Check |isbn= value: invalid character (help)CS1 maint: extra punctuation (link)
    • "Sociologically, the way of life of halakhic Judaism vouchsafed Jewry to an unambiguously distinct ... identity - an identity that was the source of a profound discomfort to those Jews who sought cultural, social, and political integration in the Gentile community in which they lived." - The Jew in the modern world: a documentary history Paul R. Mendes-Flohr (Ed.), p. 156
30. • " We recognize, in the modern era of universal culture of heart and intellect, the approaching of the realization of Israels great Messianic hope for the establishment of the kingdom of truth, justice, and peace among all men. We consider ourselves no longer a nation, but a religious community, and therefore expect neither a return to Palestine, nor a sacrificial worship under the sons of Aaron, nor the restoration of any of the laws concerning the Jewish state." - Pittsburgh Platform
31. Carl. S. Ehrlich (1999) "Joshua, Judaism, and Genocide", in Jewish Studies at the Turn of the Twentieth Century, Judit Targarona Borrás, Ángel Sáenz-Badillos (Eds). 1999, Brill. p 117-124.
32. A. G. Hunter "Denominating Amalek: Racist stereotyping in the Bible and the Justification of Discrimination", in Sanctified aggression: legacies of biblical and post biblical vocabularies of violence, Jonneke Bekkenkamp, Yvonne Sherwood (Eds.). 2003, Continuum Internatio Publishing Group, pp 92-108
33. Horowitz, Elliott S. (2006). Reckless rites: Purim and the legacy of Jewish violence. Princeton University Press. pp. 2–3, 107–146, 187–212, 213–247. ISBN 0691124914.
34. • Lustick, Ian (1988). For the land and the Lord: Jewish fundamentalism in Israel. Council on Foreign Relations. pp. 131–132. ISBN 0876090366.
    • Armstrong, Karen (2007). The Bible: a biography. Atlantic Monthly Press. pp. 211–216. ISBN 0871139693.
35. ^ Weiss, Steven I. (2010-02-26). "The Ghosts of Purim Past: The holiday's violent beginnings—and what they mean for the Jewish future".
36. ^ "Violence and Vengeance: Purim and Good Friday". Dialogika. Council of Centers on Jewish-Christian Relations. 1998-03-28.
37. Lustick For The Land and The Lord: The Evolution of Gush Emunim, by Ian S. Lustick
38. • Anti-Defamation League on JDL
    • Bohn, Michael K. (2004). The Achille Lauro Hijacking: Lessons in the Politics and Prejudice of Terrorism. Brassey's Inc. p. 67. ISBN 1574887793.
    • Federal Bureau of Investigation - Congressional Testimony
39. • U.S. Dept. of State, Country Reports on Terrorism 2004. April 2005
    • U.S. Appeals Court Affirms Designation of Kahane Chai, Kach as Terrorist Groups Washington Report on Middle East Affairs
    • Kach, Kahane Chai (Israel, extremists) Council for Foreign Relations, 20 March 2008
40. • http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/1125254.html U.S.-born Jewish terrorist suspected of series of attacks over past 12 years. By Amos Harel and Chaim Levinson. Accessed: 3 November 2009. *http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1256799061280&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FShowFull Jewish terrorist arrested for alleged series of hate crimes. By YAAKOV KATZ. Accessed: 3 November 2009.
41. • Horowitz, Elliott S. (2006). Reckless rites: Purim and the legacy of Jewish violence. Princeton University Press. pp. 6–11. ISBN 0691124914.
    • ""The Making of a Murderous Fanatic", Time magazine, March 7, 1994".
    • Rayner, John D. (1997). An understanding of Judaism. p. 57. ISBN 1571819711.
42. • Fraade, Steven D. (1994). The Other in Jewish thought and history: constructions of Jewish culture and identity",. NYU Press. pp. 145–165. ISBN 0814779905.
    • David Novak (1979) "Noahide Law: A Foundation for Jewish Philosophy (Elimination of the double standard)" in Tradition in the public square: a David Novak reader, (2008) Randi Rashkover (Ed.). p. 132-136, Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing
43. Babylonian Talmud, in Tractate Avodah Zarah 26b, as quoted by Arthur Segal, in "A Spiritual and Ethical Compendium to the Torah and Talmud", 2009, p. 228. See also Avodah Zarah 26a.
44. Maimonides, in his "Mishneh Torah", as quoted by Arthur Segal, in "A Spiritual and Ethical Compendium to the Torah and Talmud", 2009, p. 228
45. Tomson, Peter J. (1990). Paul and the Jewish law: halakha in the Letters of the Apostle to the Gentiles. Uitgeverij Van Gorcum. pp. 151–163. ISBN 9023224906.
46. Schwarz, Sidney (2008). Judaism and Justice: The Jewish Passion to Repair the World. Jewish Lights Publishing. p. 74. ISBN 1580233538.
47. 8 saved during "Shabbat from hell" (January 17, 2010) in Israel 21c Innovation News Service Retrieved 2010–01–18
48. ZAKA rescuemission to Haiti 'proudly desecrating Shabbat' Religious rescue team holds Shabbat prayer with members of international missions in Port au-Prince. Retrieved 2010–01–22
49. Goldschneider, Calvin (2002). Israel's changing society: population, ethnicity, and development. Westview Press. p. 170.
50. Plaskow, Judith (2005). The coming of Lilith. Beacon Press. pp. 147–148.

    The author writes "The existence of agunah is a crime against women, a disgrace to the Jewish community, and a violation of human rights that demands immediate remedy. It is also a symptom of the systemic exclusion of women from power and authority in traditional Judaism. .. women's powerlessness is further magnified by a larger religious system that is also entirely under male control.... In cases where a woman's husband refuses her a 'get', she can find herself in a nightmare realm, bargaining away her means of survival and occasionally even custody of her children. .. the persistent exploitation of the inequalities of Jewish divorce law is also a more deliberate attempt to curtail women's power in a time of social change... elements within the Orthodox community are using the fundamental inequity of Jewish law to ensure women's powerlessness and to reinforce the status quo."

51. ^ Haviva Ner-David (2009) "Feminism and Halakhah: The Jew Who (Still) Isn't There". In Elyse Goldstein (Ed.), New Jewish feminism: probing the past, forging the future,p 312-313. Jewish Lights Publishing.
52. • Zola, Gary Phillip (Ed.) (1996). Women rabbis: exploration & celebration. Hebrew Union College Press. pp. 2–4.
    • Nadell, Pamela S. (1999). Women Who Would Be Rabbis: A History of Women's Ordination 1889-1985. Beacon Press. pp. 30–31. {{cite book}}: Text "isbn 0807036498" ignored (help)
53. ^
    • Hartman, Tova (2007). Feminism encounters traditional Judaism: resistance and accommodation. UPNE. p. 84.
    • Katharina von Kellenbach (2001). "Overcoming the teaching of contempt". In Athalya Brenner (Ed.), A feminist companion to reading the Bible: approaches, methods and strategies, pp 190-202. Taylor & Francis.
54. Vidal, Gore (2009). Selected Essays of Gore Vidal. Random House, Inc. p. 410. ISBN 0307388689.
55. Graetz, Naomi (2005). Unlocking the garden: a feminist Jewish look at the Bible, midrash and God. Gorgias Press. p. 15. ISBN 1593330588.

    Quoting from Frymer-Kensky, Tikva (2006). Studies in Bible and feminist criticism. Jewish Publication Society. p. 161.

56. ^ Beth S. Wagner (2001). "Mitzvah and Medicine: Gender, Assimilation, and the Scientific Defense of Family Purity". In Susan Nadell (Ed.), Women and American Judaism: historical perspectives, pp.201-222, 204. UPNE.
57. • Kaye, Evelyn (1987). The hole in the sheet: a modern woman looks at Orthodox and Hasidic Judaism. L. Stuart. p. 147.

    This book quotes Rabbi Laura Geller: "Menstrual taboos are responsible for real damage to Jewish women's views of themselves and their bodies. I have met many women who learned nothing about the Torah except that they could not touch the Torah because they menstruate. . . . Their sense of themselves as 'inferior' Jews has already permeated their relationship to tradition and their own bodies."

58. • Greenberg, Steven (2005). Wrestling with God and men: homosexuality in the Jewish tradition. Univ of Wisconsin Press. pp. 3–40. ISBN 0299190943.
    • Raphael, Marc Lee (2005). Judaism in America. Columbia University Press. pp. 121–123. {{cite book}}: Text "isbn 0231120613" ignored (help)
    • Denise L. Eger (2001), "Embracing Lesbians and Gay Men", in Contemporary debates in American reform Judaism: conflicting visions, Dana Evan Kaplan (Ed.), Routledge, p. 180-192
59. Persecution of Christians:
    • Hare, Wayne D. (2005). The Theme of Jewish Persecution of Christians in the Gospel According to St Matthew. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 052102045X.
    • Judith M. Lieu (1998), "Accusations of Jewish persecution in early Christian sources", in Tolerance and intolerance in early Judaism and Christianity, Graham Stanton, Guy G. Stroumsa (Eds), Cambridge University Press, pp. 279-295.
    • E. P. Sanders (1999), "Reflections on Anti-Judaism in the New Testament and in Christianity", in Anti-Judaism and the Gospels William Reuben Farmer (Ed.), Continuum International Publishing Group, p. 272-276.
    • Klinghoffer, David (2006). Why the Jews Rejected Jesus: The Turning Point in Western History. Random House, Inc. pp. 2–3. ISBN 0385510225,. {{cite book}}: Check |isbn= value: invalid character (help)CS1 maint: extra punctuation (link)
    • For a very early example, see the claim that "Jews killed Jesus", initially stated by Paul in the New Testament (1 Thes. 2:14–15).
    • Theissen, Gerd (1998). The historical Jesus: a comprehensive guide. Fortress Press. p. 440. ISBN 0800631226.
60. ^ The Jew in the medieval book: English antisemitism, 1350-1500 by Anthony Paul Bale, Cambridge University Press, 2006, page 33.
61. ^ From rebel to rabbi: reclaiming Jesus and the making of modern Jewish culture, by Matthew B. Hoffman, Stanford University Press, 2007, pages 4-5
62. ^ Jesus in the Talmud by Peter Schäfer, Princeton University Press, 2007, p 13, 85-92, 98–100, 113, 174.
63. • Jewish history and Jewish memory: essays in honor of Yosef Hayim Yerushalmi by Yosef Hayim Yerushalmi, UPNE, 1998, page 33.
    • Why the Jews Rejected Jesus: The Turning Point in Western History by David Klinghoffer, Random House, Inc., 2006, page 154 (identifies source of criticism as King Louis IX).
    • Tolerance and intolerance in early Judaism and Christianity by Graham Stanton, Guy G. Stroumsa, Cambridge University Press, 1998, page 247 (also includes a discussion of the censorship that removed references to Jesus - see footnote #34 on page 256; includes the assertion that "Balaam" is one of the names used instead of Jesus/Yeshua).
    • Two Nations in Your Womb: Perceptions of Jews and Christians, by Israel Jacob Yuval, University of California Press, 2008, page 132.
    • Jesus outside the New Testament: an introduction to the ancient evidence by Robert E. Van Voorst, Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing, 2000, page 110 (also discusses use of name Balaam in lieu of Jesus/Yeshua).
    • Church, State, and Jew in the Middle Ages by Robert Chazan,Behrman House, Inc, 1979, page 227-230 (transcript of 1240 Paris disputation).
    • A history of the Jews by Paul Johnson, HarperCollins, 1988, page 217 (identifies critic as Nicholas Donin).
    • Rabbi Moses ha-Kohen of Tordesillas and his book Ezer ha-emunah, by Yehuda Shamir, BRILL, 1975, page 31-32 (identifies Pope Gregory IX as a critic).
64. Seidman, Naomi (2006). Faithful renderings: Jewish-Christian difference and the politics of translation. University of Chicago Press. p. 139. ISBN 0226745066,. {{cite book}}: Check |isbn= value: invalid character (help)CS1 maint: extra punctuation (link)
65. ^ David Berger, 1998, "On the Uses of History in Medieval Jewish Polemic Against Christianity", in Jewish history and Jewish memory Yosef Hayim Yerushalmi (Ed.), UPNE, pp. 32-33
66. • Waldau, Paul (2006). A communion of subjects: animals in religion, science, and ethics. Columbia University Press. p. 86. ISBN 0231136420.
    • Waldman, Shmuel (2005). Beyond a Reasonable Doubt. Feldheim Publishers. p. 243. ISBN 1583308067.
    • Gilman, Sander L. (2006). Multiculturalism and the Jews. CRC Press. pp. 94–97. ISBN 0415979188,. {{cite book}}: Check |isbn= value: invalid character (help)CS1 maint: extra punctuation (link)
    • Schwartz, Richard H. (2001). Judaism and vegetarianism. Lantern Books. pp. 133–134. ISBN 1930051247.
    • Kalechofsky, Roberta (1992). Judaism and animal rights: classical and contemporary responses. Micah Publications. ISBN 0916288358.
    • Norman Solomon, "Judaism" in The animal ethics reader (Eds. Susan Jean Armstrong, Richard George Botzler); Routledge, 2003, pages 222-223.
67. Jakobovits, Sir Immanuel (1995). Dear Chief Rabbi: from the correspondence of Chief Rabbi Immanuel Jakobovits on matters of Jewish law, ethics, and contemporary issues, 1980-1990 ("Shechitah and Cruelty to Animals" chapter). KTAV Publishing House, Inc. pp. 63–65. ISBN 0881254711.
68. • Cohen, Shaye J. D. (2005). Why aren't Jewish women circumcised?: gender and covenant in Judaism. University of California Press. pp. 207–224. ISBN 0520212509.
    • Glick, Leonard B. (2005). Marked in your flesh: circumcision from ancient Judea to modern America. Oxford University Press. pp. 115–148. ISBN 019517674X.
    • Mark, Elizabeth Wyner (2003). The covenant of circumcision: new perspectives on an ancient Jewish rite. UPNE. pp. 157–160. ISBN 1584653078.

    See also Tabory and Erez, "Circumscribed Circumcision", pages 161-167, in this book.

    • Silverman, Eric Kline (2006). From Abraham to America: a history of Jewish circumcision. Rowman & Littlefield. pp. 177–212. ISBN 0742516695.
69. Chernikoff, Helen (October 3, 2007). "Jewish "intactivists" in U.S. stop circumcising". Reuters. Retrieved 2007-11-03.
70. Goldman, PhD, Ron (2006). "Providers of Brit Shalom". Jews Against Circumcision. Retrieved 2007-10-03.

• Misplaced Pages neutral point of view disputes from May 2010
• Articles needing cleanup from May 2010
• Cleanup tagged articles without a reason field from May 2010
• Misplaced Pages pages needing cleanup from May 2010
• Judaism
• Judaism-related controversies
• Criticism of Judaism
• Criticism of religion