Misplaced Pages

Revision as of 14:41, 25 June 2020

Putinism is the political system of Russia formed during the leadership of Vladimir Putin. It is characterized by the concentration of political and financial powers in the hands of "siloviks" — current and former "people with shoulder marks", coming from a total of 22 governmental enforcement agencies, the majority of them being FSB, Police, Army and national guard of the Russian Federation. According to columnist Arnold Beichman, "Putinism in the 21st century has become as significant a watchword as Stalinism was in the 20th".

The "Chekist takeover" of the Russian state and economic assets has been allegedly accomplished by a clique of Putin's close associates and friends who gradually became a leading group of Russian oligarchs and who "seized control over the financial, media and administrative resources of the Russian state" and restricted democratic freedoms and human rights. According to some scholars, Russia has been transformed to an "FSB state". Putin himself admitted that "there is no such thing as a former KGB man" and joked that "a group of FSB colleagues dispatched to work undercover in the government has successfully completed its first mission."

Description

Sociologists, economists and politologists emphasize different features of the system.

Characteristics of Putinism highlighted by publicists and journalists

• Putin’s personality cult, creating through glorification in the media, the image of a “national hero”,
• strong presidential power, strengthened even in comparison with Yeltsin times,
• strong state control over property,
• elements of nepotism (cooperative “Ozero”),
• reliance on siloviki (people from several dozen security agencies, many of whom worked with Putin before he came to power),
• selective application of justice, subjectively selective application of the law (“Everything is for the friends, the law is for the enemies”),
• relatively liberal, but devoid of transparency, financial and tax policies,
• “manual control” mode: a weak technical government that does not have any political weight, with real control of the country from Presidential Administration,
• utmost secrecy of power and backstage making of key decisions,
• the authorities' dislike of freedom to express their opinion, censorship,
• strategic relations with The Holy Synod of the Russian Orthodox Church, they say, the property interests of the church and a policy of promoting clericalization of society.
• In the international arena, Putinism is characterized by nostalgia in Soviet times and a desire to regain the situation when USSR competed on an equal footing with USA in matters of international politics. Energy is used as an instrument of international politics (so-called “pipeline diplomacy”).

Characteristics of Putinism highlighted by scientists

M. Urnov and V. Kasamara established among political scientists “direct signs of the departure of the current political system of Russia from the basic principles of competition policy”:

• centralization, strong presidential power, weakening of the political influence of regional elites and big business
• establishment of direct or indirect state control over the main television channels of the country, censorship;
• the ever-increasing use of the “administrative resource” in elections at the regional and federal levels;
• the actual elimination of the system of separation of powers, the establishment of control over the judicial system;
• non-public style of political behavior
• monopolization of political power in the hands of the president
• priority of state interests over the interests of the individual, restriction of the rights of citizens, Reprisals against Civil Society
• creating an image of a "besieged fortress", equating opposition activities with hostile and its ousting from the political field
• Putin’s personality cult, the embodiment of state succession in it after a serious injury from the collapse of the USSR
• bureaucratic authoritarianism, the presence of the ruling party merged with the bureaucratic apparatus
• state corporativism
• strong state control over property,
• aggressive foreign policy
• focus on order and conservative values
• ideology of national greatness
• Anti-Western sentiment

Sociological studies

Sociological investigation unveiling the phenomena was done in 2004 by Olga Kryshtanovskaya, who has determined the portion of siloviks in Russian political elite as 25%. In Putin's "inner circle" which constitutes about 20 people, amount of siloviks rises to 58%, and fades to 18–20% in Parliament and 34% in the Government. According to Kryshtanovskaya, there was no capture of power as Kremlin bureaucracy has called siloviks in order to "restore order". The process of siloviks coming into power has allegedly started since 1996, Boris Yeltsin's second term. "Not personally Yeltsin, but the whole elite wished to stop the revolutionary process and consolidate the power." When silovik Vladimir Putin was appointed Prime Minister in 1999, the process was boosted. According to Olga, "Yes, Putin has brought siloviks with him. But that's not enough to understand the situation. Here's also an objective aspect: the whole political class wished them to come. They were called for service... There was a need of a strong arm, capable from point of view of the elite to establish order in the country."

Kryshtanovskaya has also noted that there were people who had worked in structures "affiliated" with KGB/FSB. Structures usually considered as such are the Soviet Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Governmental Communications Commission, Ministry of Foreign Trade, Press Agency News and others. "The itself work in such agencies doesn't involve necessary contacts with special services, but makes to think about it." Summing up numbers of official and "affiliated" siloviks she got an estimate of 77% of such in the power.

Intelligence state

According to former Securitate general Ion Mihai Pacepa, "In the Soviet Union, the KGB was a state within a state. Now former KGB officers are running the state. They have custody of the country’s 6,000 nuclear weapons, entrusted to the KGB in the 1950s, and they now also manage the strategic oil industry renationalized by Putin. The KGB successor, rechristened FSB, still has the right to electronically monitor the population, control political groups, search homes and businesses, infiltrate the federal government, create its own front enterprises, investigate cases, and run its own prison system. The Soviet Union had one KGB officer for every 428 citizens. Putin’s Russia has one FSB-ist for every 297 citizens."

"Under Russian Federation President and former career foreign intelligence officer Vladimir Putin, an "FSB State" composed of chekists has been established and is consolidating its hold on the country. Its closest partners are organized criminals. In a world marked by a globalized economy and information infrastructure, and with transnational terrorism groups utilizing all available means to achieve their goals and further their interests, Russian intelligence collaboration with these elements is potentially disastrous", said politologist Julie Anderson.

Former KGB officer Konstantin Preobrazhenskiy shares similar ideas. When asked "How many people in Russia work in FSB?", he replied: "Whole country. FSB owns everything, including Russian Army and even own Church, the Russian Orthodox Church ... Putin managed to create new social system in Russia".

"Vladimir Putin's Russia is a new phenomenon in Europe: a state defined and dominated by former and active-duty security and intelligence officers. Not even fascist Italy, Nazi Germany, or the Soviet Union – all undoubtedly much worse creations than Russia – were as top-heavy with intelligence talent", said intelligence expert Marc Gerecht.

Corporation-state

Some economists consider the political system in Russia as a variety of corporatism. According to Andrei Illarionov, a former advisor of Vladimir Putin, this is a new socio-political order, "distinct from any seen in our country before". He said that members of the Corporation of Intelligence Service Collaborators took over the entire body of state power, follow an omerta-like behavior code, and "are given instruments conferring power over others – membership “perks”, such as the right to carry and use weapons". According to Illarionov, this "Corporation has seized key government agencies – the Tax Service, Ministry of Defense, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Parliament, and the government-controlled mass media – which are now used to advance the interests of members. Through these agencies, every significant resource of the country – security/intelligence, political, economic, informational and financial – is being monopolized in the hands of Corporation members".

Members of the Corporation created an isolated caste. A former KGB general said that "a Chekist is a breed... A good KGB heritage—a father or grandfather, say, who worked for the service—is highly valued by today's siloviki. Marriages between siloviki clans are also encouraged."

Single-party bureaucratic state

Russian politician Boris Nemtsov and commentator Kara-Murza define Putinism in Russia as "a one party system, censorship, a puppet parliament, ending of an independent judiciary, firm centralization of power and finances, and hypertrophied role of special services and bureaucracy, in particular in relation to business".

State gangsterism

Political analyst Andrei Piontkovsky considers Putinism as "the highest and culminating stage of bandit capitalism in Russia”. He believes that "Russia is not corrupt. Corruption is what happens in all countries when businessmen offer officials large bribes for favors. Today’s Russia is unique. The businessmen, the politicians, and the bureaucrats are the same people. They have privatized the country’s wealth and taken control of its financial flows."

Such views are also shared by politologist Julie Anderson who said the same person can be a Russian intelligence officer, an organized criminal, and a businessman. She also cited former CIA director James Woolsey who said: "I have been particularly concerned for some years, beginning during my tenure, with the interpenetration of Russian organized crime, Russian intelligence and law enforcement, and Russian business. I have often illustrated this point with the following hypothetical: If you should chance to strike up a conversation with an articulate, English-speaking Russian in, say, the restaurant of one of the luxury hotels along Lake Geneva, and he is wearing a $3,000 suit and a pair of Gucci loafers, and he tells you that he is an executive of a Russian trading company and wants to talk to you about a joint venture, then there are four possibilities. He may be what he says he is. He may be a Russian intelligence officer working under commercial cover. He may be part of a Russian organized crime group. But the really interesting possibility is that he may be all three and that none of those three institutions have any problem with the arrangement."

According to politologist Glinsky, "The idea of Russia, Inc.--or better, Russia, Ltd.--derives from the Russian brand of libertarian anarchism viewing the state as just another private armed gang claiming special rights on the basis of its unusual power." "This is a state conceived as a "stationary bandit" imposing stability by eliminating the roving bandits of the previous era.", he said.

In April 2006, the effectively privatization of the customs sphere infuriated Putin himself, where businessmen and officials "merged in ecstasy".

Ideology

Some observers discuss ideology of new Russian political elite. Politologist Irina Pavlova said that chekists are not merely a corporation of people united to expropriate financial assets. They have long-standing political objectives of transforming Moscow to the Third Rome and ideology of "containing" the United States. Columnist George Will emphasized the nationalistic nature of Putinism. He said that "Putinism is becoming a toxic brew of nationalism directed against neighboring nations, and populist envy, backed by assaults of state power, directed against private wealth. Putinism is a national socialism without the demonic element of its pioneer...". According to Illarionov, the ideology of chekists is Nashism (“ours-ism”), the selective application of rights".

In March 2020, Vyacheslav Volodin, the Chairman of the State Duma, emphasized Vladimir Putin's special ideological role: "Today, facing the current challenges and the threats that exist in the world, oil and gas are not our advantages. As you can see, both oil and gas can fall in price. Our strength is Mr. Putin, and we must protect him".

In 2010 Peter Sucia, the American historian and the The National Interest contributor, was one of the first publicists to explicitly describe Mr. Putin as a leader who's sincerely convinced in his fascist values as righteous. Sucia wrote: "Some historians and economists have noted that fascism is actually an anti-Marxist form of socialism, especially as it favors class collaboration and supports the concept of nationalism — the latter being something that Marxists could never support. A diehard Marxist leader wouldn't get on a plane and fly halfway around the world to try and win support for the Olympics to be hosted in his country, even his hometown. But a tried and true Fascist might do so".

In June 2020, the National Interest published Putin's article with Adolf Hitler's quote about Russia. According to Russian historian Igor Petrov, Mr. Putin has quoted "Hitler's Table Talk" book, officially banned in Russia as extremist. Vladimir Putin's spokesperson has denied the use of a secondary source. One day earlier, Hitler's personal belongings, including his uniform and military cap, were opened for demonatration in a museum section of Cathedral of the Resurrection of Christ complex. Hitler sincerely believed all the Slavs, including the so-called all-Russians, are genetically sub-humans, and only the German-speaking elites have the rights to enslave them. !! V. Putin quoting & correcting I. Matvienko Finally, despite the previous academician's efforts to warn the authorities about the consequences of obscurantism propaganda in Russia, Mr. Putin's personal respect for White émigré's Ivan Ilyin's philosophy has become a distinguished part of 2020 amendments to the Constitution of Russia, effectively securing both the position of 'the new nobility' (FSB officials and oligarchs) and restoring the traditional pre-XX-century Western reputation of Russia as a backward country, with no proper future for the local science and secular culture and a lot of future for the Russian Orthodox Church ('Ortodox' — Template:Lang-ru

• "Something All Christians Can Agree On". thelibertariancatholic.com. September 22, 2018. Retrieved 22 June 2020.</ref>, and the first translation of the New Testament to Russian was published in 1820).

See also

• Russia under Vladimir Putin
• Yeltsinism
• Stalinism
• Gaullism
• Peronism
• Erdoganism

References

1. ^ Mission "intrusion" is complete! Archived 2006-07-23 at the Wayback Machine by Olga Kryshtanovskaya, 2004, Novaya Gazeta (in Russian)
2. From Communism to Putinism, by Richard Rahn, The Brussels Journal, 2007-09-21
3. ^ Russia: Putin May Go, But Can 'Putinism' Survive?, By Brian Whitmore, RFE/RL, August 29, 2007
4. The Perils of Putinism, By Arnold Beichman, Washington Times, February 11, 2007
5. Putinism On the March, by George F. Will, Washington Post, November 30, 2004
6. Beichman, Arnold (2007-02-14). "Regression in Russia". politicalmavens.com..
7. ^ The Essence of Putinism: The Strengthening of the Privatized State by Dmitri Glinski Vassiliev, Center for Strategic and International Studies, November 2000
8. What is ‘Putinism’? Archived 2009-02-05 at the Wayback Machine, by Andranik Migranyan, Russia in Global affairs, 13 April, 2004
9. ^ The Chekist Takeover of the Russian State, Anderson, Julie (2006), International Journal of Intelligence and Counter-Intelligence, 19:2, 237 – 288.
10. The HUMINT Offensive from Putin's Chekist State Anderson, Julie (2007), International Journal of Intelligence and Counter-Intelligence, 20:2, 258 – 316
11. A Chill in the Moscow Air – by Owen Matthews and Anna Nemtsova – Newsweek International, Feb. 6, 2006
12. The KGB Rises Again in Russia – by R.C. Paddock – Los Angeles Times, January 12, 2000
13. Russia Today InoTV - Die Welt: Putin’s Cult of Personality based on “politeness”
14. Sergey Samuilov “Democratization” of Afghanistan: what's new? Free Thought, Releases 10-12; Pravda Publishing House, 2007
15. Gennady Zyuganov - The Communists - 21; Algorithm Publishing House 2012; ISBN 5457273857, ISBN 9785457273856; “We are attacking, they are retreating”
16. Rogozhina Evgenia Mikhailovna - Principles and technologies for modeling political leadership in modern Russia: Monograph, 2013 NGLU; ISBN 5858392717, ISBN 9785858392712 p. 243/299
17. ^ Lonely Power Archived 2012-05-08 at the Wayback Machine: Why Russia did not become the West and why it is difficult for Russia with the West / Shevtsova L .; Mosk. Carnegie Center. - M .: Russian Political Encyclopedia (ROSSPEN), 2010. - 272 p.
18. cf. N. A. Goreva calls the system of state power built by Yeltsin "anarchist authoritarianism". Abstract of the dissertation "Transformation of the political regime in post-Soviet Russia"
19. Putin would be happy to help Russian business, but worries about consumers. // Interfax, October 28, 2011. “I fully agree with this thesis. Believe me, many of those present in the hall know that I am trying to put it into practice. ”
20. M. Prokhorov on a straight line with V. Putin: A directed show. // RBC, April 25, 2013.
21. / # element-text Radio Echo of Moscow. Separate opinion, 11/7/2012. Leonid Radzikhovsky.
22. ^ Closed government. Vladimir Putin preserves the manual control system. // Gazeta.ru
23. Putin's manual control. // Segodnia.ru, 04.25.2013.
24. Manual control session. Putin did not close another Deripaska plant to close. // Lenta.ru, December 9, 2011.
25. Christopher Walker . Ten Years of Putinism. // InoSmi, translated from The Wall Street Journal, August 14, 2009 "However, the most striking feature of Putinism is its dislike of freedom to express one’s opinion."
26. Inopress are protected for loyalty to the ROC - Peter Tide | Bild - Putin’s Whims
27. Academicians' letter
28. / 2013/10/470 / Foundation Sanity. Orthodoxy in law. Constitution funeral? Announcement.
29. Trouble in the Pipeline
30. ^ Урнов, Марк; Касамара, Валерия (2005). Современная Россия: вызовы и ответы: Сборник материалов [Modern Russia: Challenges and Answers: Collection of materials.] (in Russian). pp. 26–27.
31. ^ Dutch sociologist Marcel Van Herpen Putinism. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan; January 2013. ISBN 978-1-137-28281-1

    Van Herpen compares in detail the many and often surprising parallels that exist between Putin’s regime and that of Weimar Germany and Mussolini’s Italy, indicating the presence of strong Fascist elements in contemporary Russia.
    However, this is tempered by other elements that show a resemblance with the Bonapartism from Napoleon III’s France and the post-modern populism of Silvio Berlusconi, creating a hybrid system which can be labelled ‘Fascism-lite’. Although ‘Putinism’ has a softer face than Mussolinian Fascism, it still contains a hard core of ultra-nationalism, militarism, and neo-imperialism.

32. ^ Вишневский, Борис Лазаревич (2017-01-06). "Десять признаков путинизма" [Ten signs of Putinism]. echo.msk.ru.
33. ^ Марлен Ларюэль — Путинизм как голлизм
34. ^ социолог и политический аналитик Леон Арон: Aron, Leon (8 May 2008). "Putinism" (online). American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research: 16. Retrieved 2008-01-31. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
35. ^ What is ‘Putinism’? Archived 2009-02-05 at the Wayback Machine, by Andranik Migranyan, Russia in Global affairs, 13 April 2004 (рус.)
36. Fradkov: jacket over straps, by Olga Kryshtanovskaya, 2004 (in Russian)
37. Jamie Glazov (23 June 2006). When an Evil Empire Returns — The Cold War: It's back., interview with Ion Mihai Pacepa, R. James Woolsey, Jr., Yuri Yarim-Agaev, and Lt. Gen. Thomas McInerney, FreeRepublic.com. Retrieved 2 October 2019.
38. The Kremlin’s Killing Ways Archived 2007-12-13 at the Wayback Machine – by Ion Mihai Pacepa, National Review Online, November 28, 2006
39. http://www.voanews.com/russian/archive/2007-02/2007-02-02-voa3.cfm
40. A Rogue Intelligence State? Why Europe and America Cannot Ignore Russia By Reuel Marc Gerecht
41. ^ Andrei Illarionov: Approaching Zimbabwe (Russian) Partial English translation Archived 2007-07-05 at the Wayback Machine
42. Russia under Putin. The making of a neo-KGB state., The Economist, Aug 23, 2007
43. Russia After The Presidential Election Archived 2007-09-26 at the Wayback Machine by Mark A. Smith Conflict Studies Research Centre
44. Putinism: highest stage of robber capitalism, by Andrei Piontkovsky, The Russia Journal, February 7-13, 2000. The title is an allusion to work "Imperialism as the last and culminating stage of capitalism" by Vladimir Lenin
45. Review of Andrei's Pionkovsky's Another Look Into Putin's Soul by the Honorable Rodric Braithwaite, Hoover Institute
46. (Congressional Statement of R. James Woolsey, Former Director of the Central Intelligence Agency, 21 September 1999, Hearing on the Bank of New York and Russian Money Laundering)
47. Baev, Pavel K. (22 May 2006). "Putin's fight against corruption resembles matryoshka doll". Eurasia Daily Monitor. No. Volume: 3 Issue: 99. The Jamestown Foundation. Retrieved 10 June 2020. {{cite news}}: |issue= has extra text (help)
48. Badly informed optimists, by Irina Pavlova, grani.ru
49. "George Will". www.jewishworldreview.com. Retrieved 2019-07-06.
50. "Viacheslav Volodin: Russia's strength is not oil and gas, but Vladimir Putin". duma.gov.ru. State Duma . 12 March 2020. Retrieved 18 June 2020.
51. Suciu P., Kullman J. America's Road to Fascism: From the Progressives to the Era of Hope and Change. ISBN 9780980656718.
    • "The National Interest: у РФ есть основания опасаться вторжения НАТО" [The National Interest: Russia has a reason to be afraid of NATO invasion]. aif.ru (in Russian). Аргументы и факты. June 13, 2020. Retrieved 14 June 2020.
52. "Vladimir Putin: The Real Lessons of the 75th Anniversary of World War II". The National Interest. June 18, 2020. Retrieved 19 June 2020. Hitler clearly stated: "Our policy towards the peoples living in the vastness of Russia should be to promote any form of disagreement and division"
53. "Историк уличил Путина в использовании ненастоящей цитаты Гитлера в статье о Второй мировой войне. Из книги, которая в России признана экстремистской" [The historian exposed Putin's use of Hitler's fake quote in an article about World War II. From the book recognized as extremist in Russia] (in Russian). Latvia: Meduza. Retrieved 19 June 2020.
54. "Песков отрицает использование Путиным фейковой цитаты Гитлера" [Peskov denies Putin's use of Hitler's fake quote]. meduza.io (in Russian). Latvia: Meduza. Retrieved 23 June 2020. Everything used in Putin's article is not a transmission of someone's words, but it's a direct quotation of documents from the archives
55. Sinelshikova, Yekaterina (17 June 2020). "A giant BLACK cathedral from remelted weapons appears in Russia (PHOTOS)". rbth.com. RBTH. Retrieved 19 June 2020.
56. Grimsley, Mark. "What if Hitler Had Won World War II?". historynet.com. Historynet LLC. Retrieved 20 June 2020. The brutal "General Government" of Poland would have extended into the former Soviet Union as far as 70 degrees east longitude—a bit more than half of the entire Russian empire—and the entire region converted into a vast pool of expend able slave labor
    • "Putin Says 70% of Russians Belong to Middle Class". russiabusinesstoday.com. 18 March 2020. Retrieved 21 June 2020. He stressed that "each country has its own middle class" and it would be wrong to associate the middle-class lifestyle with the way they live in France, Germany, or the U.S.
    • "Путин объявил, что к среднему классу принадлежит больше 70% россиян. Некоторым из них хватает денег только на еду и одежду" [Putin announced more than 70% of Russians belong to the middle class. Some of them only have enough money for food and clothing]. theins.ru. The Insider. 18 March 2020. Retrieved 21 June 2020.
    • Russia was ruled by the House of Holstein-Gottorp-Romanov before 1917. The last tsar Nicholas II was described as "limited, stupid" and "degenerate" by the first Russian Nobel Prize winner, physiologist Ivan Pavlov: Todes, D. P. (2014). Ivan Pavlov: A Russian Life in Science. Oxford University Press. ISBN 9780199394449.
      • ""Идите ко мне, бандерлоги" Владимир Путин пригласил оппозицию к диалогу" ["Come closer to me, Bandar-logs", Vladimir Putin welcomes dialog with the opposition] (in Russian). Kommersant. 16 December 2011. Retrieved 5 June 2020.
      • "Идите ко мне, бандерлоги!" (in Russian). We Read Together – World of Books Navigator [ru]. 1 February 2012. Retrieved 5 June 2020.
    • Modern nationalist propaganda about Bolshevik's lack of rights to enslave the people of Russia: Kholmogorov, Egor (24 August 2016). "Кто кого кормил в СССР" [Who had been feeding whom in the USSR?]. kp.ru (in Russian). Komsomolskaya Pravda. Retrieved 23 June 2020. Lenin's national policy" constructed political, cultural and economic relations in the USSR that way, they mostly began to resemble the proverb "one with a plow, and seven with a spoon." Moreover, it was not a random mistake, not a bias, but a conscious policy of the Bolsheviks who believed that it was necessary to humiliate the Russian people, due to their Great Power Chauvinism [ru], in order to exalt the others. Even the head of the Soviet government, Rykov, was dismissed from his position after declaring that "he considers it unacceptable the other peoples live at the expense of the Russian peasant.
    • John McCain about Putin's Russophobia: "Putin 'Doesn't Believe In You,' McCain Tells Russian People". npr.org. September 19, 2013. Retrieved 23 June 2020.
    • Aleksei Navalny about American philosopher Francis Fukuyama's 1992 predictive statement about Russophobia as a traditional value among the Russian ruling class: "Алексей Навальный поспорил с автором книги «Конец истории» Фрэнсисом Фукуямой — о популизме, либерализме и Грете Тунберг. Вот как это было" [Alexei Navalny has argued with the author of The End of History, Francis Fukuyama, about populism, liberalism, and Greta Thunberg. That's how it was] (in Russian). Meduza. 15 October 2019. Retrieved 23 June 2020.
    • Brophy, Timothy S. (2019). The Oxford Handbook of Assessment Policy and Practice in Music Education, Volume 1. Oxford University Press. ISBN 9780190248116.
    • "Музыкальные предпочтения" [Musical Preferences] (in Russian). Levada Center. February 18, 2019. Retrieved 23 June 2020. Classical music - 22%
    • "Майя Плисецкая: «После «Лебединого озера» я была просто вывернута наизнанку" [Maya Plisetskaya: “After the Swan Lake I've been just turned inside out]. aif.ru (in Russian). Argumenty i Fakty. 17 October 2010. Retrieved 21 June 2020. According to Plisetskaya, Boléro, as well as Carmen, included the most terrible thing in the world for the Soviet officials — sex
57. "Владимир Путин — о трех китах, на которых держится рэп" [Vladimir Putin about the three whales which support rap]. the-village.ru (in Russian). The Village. 15 December 2018. Retrieved 21 June 2020. You said rap and the other contemporary cultures rest on three pillars - sex, drugs and protest. Out of these, drugs worry us the most. This is a path to nation's degradation. They like to do this somewhere over the hill, and, help them God, let them do what they want. We must think about doing the work for this not to happen
58. "The Importance Of Judo For Vladimir Putin". rferl.org. Radio Liberty. June 19, 2012. Retrieved 25 June 2020. Judo has always been more than a sport for Putin. As he told NPR in 2001: "I think it's also a philosophy in a way, and I think it's a philosophy that teaches one to treat one's partner with respect. And I engage in this sport with pleasure and try to have regular practices still."
    • "«Этой формулировкой Путин точно закладывает мину. Кто такие русские?»" [“With this statement, it's like Putin is laying down a bomb. Who are the Russians?”]. business-gazeta.ru (in Russian). Business Online. 4 March 2020. Retrieved 23 June 2020. The phrase about the "state-forming people" in the Constitution will be softened by the "multinational union of equal peoples". But does it change the meaning?
59. "ФСБ - дворянство, которого не было" [FSB, nobility that didn't exist]. www.svoboda.org (in Russian). Radio Liberty. 29 September 2010. Retrieved 19 June 2020.
60. "Михаил Пиотровский - Разбор полёта" [Mikhail Piotrovsky in ""Razbor Polyota"] (in Russian). Echo of Moscow. 17 June 2019. Retrieved 23 June 2020. Mikhail Piotrovsky: We perceive religion as a part of culture. The Church and the politicians perceive culture as an assistant to religion
    • Serebryany, Igor (29 May 2019). "Why building churches in Russia is of higher priority than building schools". fairplanet.org. FairPlanet. Retrieved 21 June 2020. But when the Russians see that their local authorities contribute public funds to church construction instead of investing money into ailing housing and utilities, that annoys people
    • "Russians Return to Religion, But Not to Church". pewforum.org. Pew Research Center. 10 February 2014. Retrieved 21 June 2020.
61. "The Russian Language". YouTube. Canada: Langfocus. 26 June 2016. Retrieved 20 June 2020. Brief history of Russian - Old Church Slavonic peculiar relationships
62. "2010 Secretary Clinton's RemarksRemarks by Secretary Clinton: March 2010 Interview With Vladimir Pozner of First Channel Television". 2009-2017.state.gov. March 19, 2010. Retrieved 19 June 2020. We have 40,000 Russians living in Silicon Valley in California
63. "Ivan Ilyin, Putin's Philosopher of Russian Fascism". The New York Review of Books. April 5, 2018. Retrieved December 12, 2019. The proper interpretation of the "judge not" passage was that every day was judgment day, and that men would be judged for not killing God's enemies when they had the chance. In God's absence, Ilyin determined who those enemies were
    • "Президент Эстонии: Россия не будет нападать на НАТО". dw.com (in Russian). Deutsche Welle. 18 May 2017. Retrieved 20 June 2020. Russians are the people with a great culture, they have a good sense of humour. In Russia, there's an excellent scientific sphere. I really appreciate the Russian people. If I think about the Russian state, then today it is a threat to the value-oriented system of international security. But, to my mind, these two aspects are completely separated
    • The same interview, in English, doesn't consist the exact quote: "Estonian President Kaljulaid: 'I don't believe that Russia would attack a NATO country'". dw.com. Deutche Welle. Retrieved 20 June 2020.
    • "Александр Невзоров — Невзоровские среды" [Aleksandr Nevzorov — Nevzorov's Wednesdays/Environments]. echo.msk.ru. Echo of Moscow. 17 June 2020. Retrieved 20 June 2020. After all, when the Russian is planning the relations with Russia, with its authorities, he or she always keeps in mind the opportunity to get the hell out of Russia and forget this country like a bad dream. And partly, it explains the amazing tolerance of Russians for all the events of recent decades
64. "Триада, которой нет в Конституции: мракобесие, репрессии, сословность" [The Triad which is not in the Constitution: obscurantism, repression, casta] (in Russian). Republic.ru. 4 June 2020. Retrieved 11 June 2020. Putin's lame eternity has three crutches: purposeful archaization of mass consciousness, constant invention of the enemies with their subsequent capture, and formation of a complex class of the new nobles endowed with special rights which are different from the rights of commoners
    • ""Кухаркины дети". Как закон в сфере образования привёл к крушению империи" ["Cook's children." How did the education law caused the crash of Russian Empire] (in Russian). Argumenty i fakty. July 1, 2017. Retrieved September 5, 2019. Thus, with the strict observance of this rule, gymnasiums and a professional gymnasiums will be freed from the arrival of children of coachmen, footmen, cooks, laundresses, small shopkeepers and the alikes, whose children, with the exception of those gifted with genial abilities, should not strive for a secondary and higher education at all
    • "Протоиерей Чаплин: Моцарт - это "Бритни Спирс своего времени". Fontanka.ru [ru]. 5 April 2012. Retrieved 20 June 2020. Vsevolod Chaplin "I don't like Mozart. I believe, to a large extent, this is Britney Spears of his time. With the exception of certain brilliant insights, he was writing monotonous and poppy things"
    • "Шуберта не читал, но осуждаю" [I didn't read Schubert but I condemn him]. svoboda.org. Radio Liberty. 21 August 2017. Retrieved 21 June 2020. Two news that look good together. Putin reminded the students Schubert was using the prostitutes' services, became ill and died. Tikhon Khrennikov's grandson praised Putin's musical abilities
    • "Кто самый музыкально одарённый президент в мировой истории?" [Who's the most musically gifted President?]. kultshpargalka.ru (in Russian). Retrieved 21 June 2020. Our president has analyzed the experience of foreign colleagues and concluded the grand piano somehow ennobles the presidential image. Therefore, at a certain stage, he stopped publicly expressing his affection for the group "Lyube", and now he speaks about the great significance of the works of Tchaikovsky, Glinka and other Russian classics. And once, he even admitted that if he had a time, he would even listen to Mozart, Schubert and Liszt. "Schubert in the treatment of Liszt or Liszt in the treatment of Schubert." But there is no time.
    • "К чему приведут реформы в детских музыкальных школах" [What will result in the reforms of children musical schools?]. rg.ru (in Russian). Rossiyskaya Gazeta. 10 April 2019. Retrieved 17 January 2020.
    • Shvydkoy, Mikhail (March 19, 2019). "Инженер с флейтой" [Engineer with Flute]. rg.ru (in Russian). Rossiyskaya Gazeta. Retrieved 23 June 2020. The officials demand explantion what the taxpayar's money is going to do, and is it not better to spend it on something more useful. Simple answer, such as "we take the children away, most often, unsecured children away from the street", or "we are preparing an artistically educated audience", seem unconvincing to many
    • About Communism being to Russian Orthodoxy approximately the same as Protestantism to Roman Catholicism: "Communism, religion, and unhappiness". voxeu.org. 26 April 2018. Retrieved 23 June 2020. "The best type of communist, that is to say, the man who is completely in the grip of the service of an idea and capable of enormous sacrifices and disinterested enthusiasm, is a possibility only as the result of the Christian training of the human spirit, of the remaking of the natural man by the Christian spirit" (Berdyaev 1937: 170)

Further reading

• Putin’s Militocracy by Olga Kryshtanovskaya and Stephen White
• Russia under Putin. The making of a neo-KGB state., The Economist, Aug 23, 2007
• Russia's government. Putin's people., The Economist, Aug 23, 2007
• The power of Chekists is incredibly stable by Olga Kryshtanovskaya
• The Chekist Takeover of the Russian State, Anderson, Julie (2006), International Journal of Intelligence and Counter-Intelligence, 19:2, 237 – 288.
• The HUMINT Offensive from Putin's Chekist State Anderson, Julie (2007), International Journal of Intelligence and Counter-Intelligence, 20:2, 258 – 316
• Russia: Death and resurrection of the KGB By J. Michael Waller, Demokratizatsiya: The Journal of Post-Soviet Democratization
• A Rogue Intelligence State? Why Europe and America Cannot Ignore Russia By Reuel Marc Gerecht

• Conservatism in Russia
• Eponymous political ideologies
• Politics of Russia
• Russian nationalism
• Vladimir Putin